The Career Path Is Rarely a Straight Line

In an earlier article, we talked about career pathways and how they give people a future they can see. But there is a common assumption hiding inside most pathway and succession conversations: that careers move in a straight line up the ladder. If you do this, it will lead to that. Supervisor to manager. Manager to director. Director to vice president.

Sometimes it works that way. Most of the time, it does not.

Real careers bend. They include lateral moves, new functions, special projects, and the occasional step that looks sideways on paper but turns out to be the most important move someone ever made. When leaders treat development as a ladder with only one direction, they miss talent that is sitting right in front of them, and sometimes they put good people in the wrong place.

Why the straight line is so appealing

The linear model is easy to explain and easy to draw. It fits neatly into an org chart and a succession grid. It feels fair, because everyone can see the next rung.

The problem is that the ladder assumes the next role up is the right role for the person, and that the business needs that person to keep climbing in the same lane. Neither is always true. A strong individual contributor may not want to lead people. A capable operations manager may have the exact strengths the business needs in customer success. A technical expert may grow faster through a cross-functional assignment than through another promotion in the same department.

A straight line is simple. It is not always accurate.

The value of moving sideways

A lateral move is not a demotion, a detour, or a consolation prize. Done with intent, it is one of the most effective development tools a leader has.

Lateral moves can:

  • Broaden perspective. People who have worked in more than one part of the business understand how the pieces connect. That is exactly what the business needs from its future leaders.

  • Build missing competencies. If the gap analysis shows someone needs experience with budgets, customers, or cross-functional influence, a lateral role may close that gap faster than any course.

  • Test readiness safely. A new role at the same level lets someone stretch without the risk of a big step up before they are ready.

  • Keep good people engaged. When the next rung is not open, a meaningful lateral move tells someone the organization is still investing in them.

Many of the strongest leaders you know likely took at least one sideways step that made their later success possible.

The disservice of misplaced talent

A mentor of mine once said, "You may be able to fit a square peg in a round hole, but there will always be large gaps."

That is the cost of misplaced talent. When someone is in a role that does not fit their strengths, interests, or ambitions, everyone pays for it.

  • People. The employee works harder for weaker results, and confidence erodes. Frustration builds, engagement drops, and good people either leave or go quiet.

  • Strategy. The role is not being performed at the level the business needs, and the person's real strengths are not being used where they could make a difference.

  • Revenues. Underperformance in the role, lost productivity, and the eventual cost of turnover all show up on the bottom line.

Misplaced talent is rarely anyone's fault. It often happens because someone was promoted for being great at their previous job, or because a vacancy needed filling quickly, or because no one asked the person what they actually wanted. But leaving it in place is a choice, and it is a costly one.

The kindest and most productive thing a leader can do is to recognize the gap and help the person find a role where the fit is real.

Development creates the balance

Another critical reason that non-linear growth is so important is that there may be a traffic jam on the ladder. When incumbents are performing at a high level, leaders are working to retain them too. While the answer for that person may be a lateral move, the challenge is finding a way to keep successors engaged and still equip them for future growth.

Leadership brings the view of the business: where it is headed, which roles will matter, and what capabilities the organization will need. That means there will always be competing priorities. Effective communication and collaboration between leaders and the team members they are developing is critical.

When only one side is talking, development goes off track. Leadership alone tends to slot people into the openings that exist. The employee alone tends to aim at titles without a clear picture of what the business needs. Together, they can find the path where personal growth and business need meet.

A real development partnership includes:

  • Honest conversations about fit. Not just "what is next?" but "where do you do your best work, and where do you struggle?"

  • Shared ownership of the plan. The team member owns their growth. Leadership owns the opportunities, support, and feedback.

  • Openness to more than one direction. Up, sideways, into a new function, or deeper as a specialist. The right answer depends on the person, the business, and other key talent already in place.

  • Regular check-ins. People change. Businesses change. Turnover happens. The path should be revisited, not set once and forgotten.

This is where the coaching and mentoring we have discussed come into play. Coaching helps someone perform well in the role they have. Mentoring helps them explore the roles they might want next. Both depend on trust and candor between the leader and the team member.

What this means for succession planning

Succession plans fall into the same linear trap. Leaders often look only one level down for successors, in the same department, following the same path the current role holder took.

The best successor may be somewhere else entirely. Someone in a different function may have the competencies the future role requires, along with a broader view of the business. When you build your bench based on competencies and readiness rather than reporting lines, your options grow.

Questions to consider

  • Are your career paths drawn only as ladders, or do they include lateral and cross-functional moves?

  • Do you have anyone in a role that fits the org chart but not the person?

  • When was the last time you asked a team member where they do their best work?

  • Does your succession plan look beyond the next level down in the same department?

The bottom line

Careers are rarely a straight line, and development should not pretend they are. Lateral moves build broader leaders, test readiness, and keep good people engaged. Misplaced talent costs the person and the business. And the best paths are found when leaders and team members build them together.

People. Strategy. Revenues.

How TruePointe Horizon can help

At TruePointe Horizon, we help organizations design development and career paths that reflect how people actually grow. Through competency-based assessment and gap analysis, we help you see where your people fit best, where lateral moves make sense, and how to build development plans that are a true partnership between leaders and team members. This work can stand on its own or be part of a broader talent development or succession planning project.

If you are ready to look beyond the ladder, let's talk.

Previous
Previous

Speed to Reset: Why Recovery Is a Critical Team Skill

Next
Next

Choosing ON Purpose… WITH Purpose